Automata online forum FAQ:
- What are Automata? Because of their diversity, automata are difficult to define. Here is our loose definition of them: "Machines that replicate human, animal, or inanimate objects’ motions, capabilities, and/or everyday tasks. These can be hand cranked, motor driven, or computer controlled.” This definition may be expanded as time flows.
- What is this Automata online forum for? This forum is to enhance communication within the Automata community. All topics related to Automata are welcome here, including design, construction, tools, materials, collecting, history, restoration, and more. In addition we have provided a sub-forum for "Buying, Selling, and Wanted" conversations.
- How do I subscribe to the Automata online forum? Go to this link and follow the instructions.
- After I subscribe where will I find the messages? The default setting for the forum is that all message threads will be emailed to each subscriber. You can reply to messages and begin new ones from your email app. Additionally, you can view and reply to the messages on the Automata online forum website. There are other options that you can see/choose on your subscription page on the Automata online forum website.
- Can photos be posted to the Automata online forum? Yes, photos are welcome. Note that all photos submitted will be resized to be no larger than 1024 X 1024 pixels.
- Can Video be posted to the Automata online forum? Sorry, no. We have limited storage space. Please post to another service (YouTube, for example) and then post a link to your video.
- Can I post messages to this forum without subscribing? Yes. All messages from non-subscribers will be approved by a moderator before appearing as a forum post.
- What is the advantage of becoming a subscriber? As a subscriber you will have message delivery options. Non-subscribers must visit the Automata Forum website to view the messages. Subscribers will automatically receive new messages.
- Why are my messages moderated? In an effort to eliminate spam from this forum, the first two messages from all subscribers will be passed by a moderator. Once approved, the messages will become public. All messages from non subscribers will be passed-by a moderator for approval. The 'moderation delay' will rarely exceed four hours during the business day.
- When was this forum started? This forum began in June 2019.
- I want more help understanding this forum platform: Take a look at this GroupsIO help page, or post your question here in the forum and someone will help you.
- Are you going to sell my information? No, we are not.
- Why are some Automata online forum features disabled? The following features have by default been disabled: Calendar, Chats, Database, Files, and Polls. Any of these features will be enabled as need arises.
- How do I make a New Topic post? There are two ways:
- From your email application address an email to the group (automata@automatamagazine.
groups.io). Fill in the Subject, and then type your message. Then Send. Your new message will be sent to all members of the group. - From your browser go to the Automata Magazine group forum on the Internet (https://automatamagazine.
groups.io/g/automata). Scan down the menu until you see New Topic. Click on New Topic and you will be taken to a screen that will let you post a new message.
- First, note that video files are too large for this group forum...so they won't be accepted. You should instead send a link to your video. Your video may be hosted anywhere. I host mine at YouTube.
- If you are using your email application to make the post simply attach an image(s). The image(s) will be resized by the groups.io platform to max dimension 1000 pixels.
- If you are posting your new post from the forum website, look up into the toolbar and you will see an "Add Pictures" icon.
- There is no drop down that shows a list of topics.
- If you want to make a post about "My Favorite Suppliers" simply include that text in the subject line. Same with "What's on My Workbench". Simply include in the subject line something like this..."What's On My Bench: This is how I animate a lizard tail".
- From your email application address an email to the group (automata@automatamagazine.
Re: Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
Gus
This video is an eye opener for what it takes to make a Junod automaton. The workshop, the equipment, the staff.....
https://youtu.be/i3hPpcJNK_s
|
|
Re: Paul Spooner's 1998 Cabaret Mechanical Theatre Anubis Paper Cutout "Magic Soup"
Ron K
Thanks Jim. Too funny, I'm recovering from surgery and when up for my last walk-a-bout, just brought my copies of each, and Rodney Peppe's Automata and Mechanical Toys, back to bed with me.
R
|
|
Re: Ron K...thanks for the Teddy the Artist images
Dominique Corbin
Thanks Ron!
Very ingenious and full of good mechanical ideas !
|
|
Re: Paul Spooner's 1998 Cabaret Mechanical Theatre Anubis Paper Cutout "Magic Soup"
Jim Larson
Can't really help with info on "Magic Soup". But you can find out more about the Geneva mechanism (also called the Geneva Stop mechanism) in Ellen Rixford's Figures in the Fourth Dimension (pp. 42-43 and 317-318) and in Keisuke Saka's Karakuri (pp. 30, 45, and 101 - a nice paper model).
Googling for "Design of Geneva Mechanism" will yield some useful technical information to guide your design.
|
|
Paul Spooner's 1998 Cabaret Mechanical Theatre Anubis Paper Cutout "Magic Soup"
Ron K
Not being endowed with the " . . . creativity, invention, artistry, exception skill, and virtuosity. " Mr. Rudd specifies as necessary to advance the art of automata (Automata Magazine, Volume 2, Number 4, July August 2020 Confessions of a part-time automatics by Randall Rudd) I'm afraid I must content myself to use that of others.
Hence I'm trying to locate information on the Paul Spooner paper cutout "Magic Soup" once available from Cabaret Mechanical Theatre. I went off on an incorrect tangent mistaken in thinking it had been included in the 1986 "Moving Animals" before I used Archive.org to check how it has been sold. Ayway, now I have a copy of "Moving Animals" in my reference library LOL. I'm particularly interested in what I suspect is a Gineva mechanism similar to the one described by Cecilia Schuller in the issue I reference above to rotate the egg, chick, and roast chicken. If I was patient I could simply wait until the next issue for her description, but here we are. TIA Ron
|
|
Re: Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
The craftsmanship is exquisite! What a treat to see. Thanks -Jim in San Diego-
Too funny, just stumbled across an old Dug North post with a YouTube link.https://youtu.be/ivIHcHwR6b0
|
|
Re: Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
Ron K
Too funny, just stumbled across an old Dug North post with a YouTube link.https://youtu.be/ivIHcHwR6b0
|
|
Re: Teddy the Artist
Many thanks to both of you for this. It's an intriguing little machine. Your summary of how it works is a nice read. Craig...your build looks very capable. It will be fun to see how it turns out. Thanks for participating in this forum. -Jim in San Diego-
On Fri, 3 Jul 2020 at 05:10, Craig <craiglonghurst@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Motors: was Re: [automata-forum] WIP "The Politician" Eye Mechanism
Good morning Gus... Thanks for responding. Having an electronics store close with inventory that you can actually feel and see is a valuable asset. You are fortunate. I understand now about your desire for DC. Thanks for explaining. Yes, a wall wart is one of those cords that has a little box on the end that plugs into the wall. The little box converts the wall electricity to something else. Please update this thread with your choice of motor and controller after you have made the decision. At least I would like to know how you resolved. Building the automata (and using a hand-crank during the build) is really important. It is through the hand-crank that you get a good feel for how things are functioning. Thanks for participating in this forum. -Jim in San Diego-
On Thu, 2 Jul 2020 at 16:16, Gus <klekner@...> wrote:
|
|
Re: Teddy the Artist
Craig
Hi Everyone,
It's been a few weeks since, so thought I'd best post an update.
With huge thanks to Ron K we now have the answer to Teddy's secret. I found a non-working Teddy the Artist for sale in the US but the seller wouldn't ship to the UK. Fortunately Ron had developed an interest in the mechanism and made the purchase himself. Ron began careful disassembly and has uploaded many photos of the inner workings to an album in the 'Photos' section of this group.
Long story short, we were on the right track. Kim's earlier theory about something 'walking' around the perimeter of the pattern, and Dominique's suggestion of using a magnet was spot on.
Being in a non-working state we have had to study the static components of the mechanism. So far Ron and I have been able to deduce the following: Follower:
Raising of magnet to clear pattern:
Pincer arms:
Patterns:
I have started building my own version of Teddy using Meccano parts (I'm a keen Meccano model builder!). After contacting various magnet suppliers in the UK (and making several purchases of different cylindrical magnets which turned out to be hopeless) I settled on a 4mm x 20mm Alnico-5 rod. A small square Meccano plate (set as a diamond) has been used for the pattern. My intention is to use interchangeable metal cookie cutter shapes but I need to source some others because the ones I tried didn't have large enough curves to allow the magnet to follow freely. I've uploaded a short video of my current development here: https://1drv.ms/v/s!AvLBm-8v6v7jmHPdRijvpG81X9g3?e=dPVim4 Next step is to add a desk and attach a pencil via a wire arm to the end of the follower. Best wishes,
Craig
|
|
Re: Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
Jim Larson
Goggle for Francois Junod to see a contemporary example of a writing automaton. His work is amazing!
Also, have a look at Ellen Rixford's wonderful book, Figures in the Fourth Dimension. She devotes 30 pages to the details of Henri Maillardet's writing and drawing automaton from the early 1800's. Yes, that's not contemporary, but the details of how it works would help you understand any recent work in the same vein.
|
|
Re: Motors: was Re: [automata-forum] WIP "The Politician" Eye Mechanism
Gus
Hi Jim,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
DC negates the need for a power outlet, does not need a wall, can be in the middle of a room for example, doesn't have a trailing cord etc. That's why I prefer that option. DC motors from what I can see are easy to source too. There is an electronics store here which has a range of geared motors, AC and DC, and plug in speed controllers. Makes selection easier than an online order from overseas suppliers. Initially, I will set up the "engine room" as manual, see how much effort it needs to operate everything, then find a suitable motor. It may be that the input speed and torque is easier to find than I am supposing. Then the motor RPM can be ordered to suit. All grist for the mill ! By the way, what is a "wall wart", a power outlet on a wall, or something else ? Regards, Gus Keep Safe
|
|
Re: Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
Craig
Also, if you haven't already seen it, Shasa Bolton has a great 5-page article in the Jan/Feb 2020 issue (Automata Magazine) that covers writing automata and his wonderful Skrippy writer.
Craig
|
|
Ron K...thanks for the Teddy the Artist images
Hi Ron... Thanks for purchasing and uploading. Looks complicated. Will try to digest later today. Mystery solved! Thanks again for the images! Cheers -Jim Coffee- one of the Automata Group Moderators I create automata near San Diego, California
|
|
Re: Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
Ron K
Here is a recent discussion: https://automatamagazine.groups.io/g/automata/message/461
|
|
Motors: was Re: [automata-forum] WIP "The Politician" Eye Mechanism
Hi Gus...
I agree with you that an automata has a 'golden speed'...a speed that is perfect for it. So I understand you wanting variable speed motors. This motor thread will go for a while I think. I hope others will join this conversation. Between us all we have collective knowledge that is greater than any individual. I appreciate this forum and the opportunity to learn and to share. Regards from San Diego, California -Jim Coffee-
On Tue, 30 Jun 2020 at 22:26, Gus <klekner@...> wrote:
|
|
Are there any recent automata that write letters or draw pictures?
autopilotjim
Like many of us, I'm fascinated by the writer and the draftsman found in these two links:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ux2KW20nqHU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZiH7oF3OMM Are there any modern-day equivalent devices? Thanks
|
|
Re: WIP "The Politician" Eye Mechanism
Gus
And to you Jim,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Thank you for your comments and help with motor information and sources. Until now, all 15 automata built have been manual, driven by hand. I have found that they have an optimum crank speed, all different, even though governed by a gear train. I expect that this will apply equally to motor driven mechanics. Having no experience with motors, and to avoid the purchase of a number of them, I am considering an external speed control, but not decided anything yet. With the exception of a gear motor being DC. In a similar vein, the cams would be much smaller blank than I am used to working with. All these aspects, and others, have to do with having to think of every single component of the total concept during the building, and is dictated by the absence of working drawings and specific planning. Would you discuss your use of a fuse, what type, does it cut in on overload, and also if there a change in the load, ie a component disconnects ? Not happy to read that the virus is spreading fast and furious in your country ! Regards, Gus Stay Safe
|
|
Re: WIP "The Politician" Eye Mechanism
Greeting Gus... Very ingenious and inventive. I believe that I've been able to follow all of the motion paths and that I understand what you have created. What a joy to see an automata like this under construction! Your mechanism looks solid and functional. Thanks very much for sharing this! Please keep posting your progress. Regarding variable speed motors...I have little experience. A top-level question that I have is "why" do you want a variable speed motor? In the end, do you want a single-speed motor and you are going to experiment with speeds until you are pleased? Or something else? If you are just going to experiment you could use something that you already have laying around like a variable speed electric drill. Or, a sewing machine motor and pedal. In the end, I suspect that you will want a gear motor. Gear motors come both constant speed or variable speed. Here is an eBay link to 115 vac gear motors: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2380057.m570.l1311.R3.TR11.TRC1.A0.H0.Xgear+motor.TRS0&_nkw=gear+motor+115v&_sacat=0 Here is an eBay link to variable speed gear motors: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313.TR2.TRC1.A0.H1.Xgear+motor%2C+variable+speed.TRS0&_nkw=gear+motor%2C+variable+speed&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=gear+motor+115v%2C+variable+speed And here is an eBay link to sewing machine motors: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1311.R1.TR12.TRC2.A0.H0.Xsewing+machine+mo.TRS0&_nkw=sewing+machine+motor&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=gear+motor%2C+variable+speed You will notice that the world of variable speed gear motors is smaller. And something that surprised me...a sewing machine motor and foot pedal combination is relatively inexpensive Thanks again for sharing -Jim in San Diego-
On Sun, 28 Jun 2020 at 16:23, Gus <klekner@...> wrote: The mechanism has two parts - a hinge section which is fixed to the hollowed out head, and the eyes which are part of a device to move them side to side and up/down. The eyes section connect to the hinge by a clamp, which allows adjustment to the eye sockets. The hinge has a return spring eliminating the need for hard wire controls, in favour of cable/cam.
|
|
Re: WIP "The Politician" Eye Mechanism
Gus
The mechanism has two parts - a hinge section which is fixed to the hollowed out head, and the eyes which are part of a device to move them side to side and up/down. The eyes section connect to the hinge by a clamp, which allows adjustment to the eye sockets. The hinge has a return spring eliminating the need for hard wire controls, in favour of cable/cam.
The eye mechanism front view Eye mechanism rear and cable connections The assembly fitted to the head The face, eyes fitted. I have made a video of the movements, but not able to post here. Jim, Thanks for your comments. I would want to use a speed controller for the motor. Have you used speed control, and if so, is there power loss ? Regards, Gus Keep safe
|
|